Clinton Cider Mill’s season runs through Thanksgiving weekend on its 1927 press
The Elm Street mill, in Clinton since 1903, is open daily through Nov. 29 and taking Thanksgiving pie orders. Its hydraulic press dates to 1927.
By Tom Brezinski

The Clinton Cider Mill at 28 Elm Street has about a week left in its season. The mill’s visiting page says it is open every day from late August through Thanksgiving weekend, 10 a.m. to 6 p.m. Monday through Saturday and 10 a.m. to 5 p.m. on Sunday. Thanksgiving falls on Nov. 26 this year, so that weekend ends Sunday, Nov. 29.
For most of the village, the last stretch means pies. The mill’s homepage says Thanksgiving pie order forms are available now, and the form it links to lists large fruit pies including apple, Dutch apple, Honeycrisp, pumpkin, pecan and cherry, smaller fruit pies, and a long run of frozen pot pies from turkey and shepherd’s to lobster. The linked form still shows last year’s pickup dates, so anyone ordering should confirm the pickup day by calling the mill at 315-853-5756.
A steam press, then a hydraulic one
The business goes back more than a century. According to the mill’s history page, the Wentworth family made cider for farmers in Madison Center before moving the operation to Clinton around the turn of the last century. The mill opened in Clinton in 1903 with a screw press powered by a steam engine.
In 1927 the Wentworths installed a hydraulic press. The mill says the cider-making process has stayed the same since then, apart from the addition of screening and refrigeration. The yellow gambrel-roofed building now carries “1927” on the sign over its porch.
John and Mimi Fehlner bought the mill in 1998. Their son, Ben, and daughter-in-law, Laura, moved to Clinton in 2006, and the family has kept making sweet cider the way it has been made there for more than a century.
Clinton has a habit of keeping old buildings at work. The village’s first public school is apartments on Marvin Street now, and in nearby Utica, the West End brewery has been making beer in Utica since 1888. The cider mill belongs on that list, with the difference that it still does the job it was built for.
How the 1927 press works
The mill laid out its process in a 2020 post on its own site. The hydraulic press is the original one the Wentworth family brought to Clinton, repaired over the years but never replaced.
Apples are washed in a custom washing machine and carried up an elevator to a grinder, which turns the whole apple, skin, core, seeds and stem, into a coarse sauce. Pressers lay a rack on the press, cover it with a cloth, release a layer of ground apple onto the cloth and fold it into a tight package. About ten of those layers are stacked one on another. The stack of racks, cloth and fruit is called a cheese, and the mill says it has to be stacked evenly.
The cheese is then rolled under the press and squeezed at 2,000 to 3,000 pounds per square inch. The juice runs into pipes below, passes through a final strainer and goes to a holding tank before it is pumped to refrigerated tanks for sale. The dry pulp left in the cloths, called pomace, goes to a bin outside and is fed to sheep.
More than cider
The mill also sells apples, donuts and baked goods from the shop, and the porch signs in the 2023 photo above advertise cheese, maple, honey, pies and sweet cider. Its lodging page lists two rentals in the village, a single-room cottage at $165 to $210 a night and a two-bedroom apartment at $190 to $260, both before tax and both about a five-minute walk from the mill.
The village around Elm Street has seen other investment lately. State money from the Clinton and Kirkland downtown grant is paying for a list of projects in the village, which the Courier tracked in where Clinton and Kirkland’s $10 million downtown grant has gone so far.
After Thanksgiving weekend, the mill’s posted season ends; its hours page puts the next opening in late August. Hours and pie orders can be confirmed at 315-853-5756.